When it comes to the things we want to do or do not want to do, we want what we want. Anyone who has spent any time at all with a 2 year old knows the truth in this statement – we do not like it when others put boundaries on us. Hopefully, as we grow, we learn to accept boundaries from authority figures (including God). This is true when it comes to living pure/holy/moral lives as well. There are several ways to respond when God/Parents/Authority figures say “No!” (or do/go/stop/etc.).
I have a grandson, Roland, who has just turned 4. This child is and was rebelious from the get go. He simply does not want to do something if others tell him to do it and wants to do it if they tell him not to. In teaching him to say “I’m sorry” after accidentally hurting someone (which happens quite often), we came to a head-to-head crisis. At the crisis point, I had him on my lap, holding him there until he said “I’m sorry”. It was a 45 minute struggle, and I was certainly tempted to let it go. However, I understood that this was an important thing for him to learn. Fortunately, I am stronger than he is. Finally, after 45 minutes, he said, “I’m sorry.” Game over, Grandma wins. What Roland didn’t realize is that he won too. He had learned a lesson about boundaries and doing what’s right.
Where’s the line?
Another incident that sticks in my mind with Roland happened early on. The molding between the family room and kitchen is the “no cross zone” at our house (at the time). I remember well the day Roland walked up to the line. Grandma said, “No!” firmly. He turned, looked at me full in the eyes, and stuck his toe over the line. His eyes said, “This is a challenge. Do you mean what you say or not?” Grandma took the challenge, and Roland discovered that even a toe over the line is disobedience.
The distraction technique
The next disobedience technique comes from my not-quite-two granddaughter. She learned early, that if she could distract the adult telling her no, she could reach up with the other hand, swipe the item, and run like a bunny rabbit. She thought she could get away with it if she wasn’t seen. Of course, this didn’t work very often. Sometimes it does work because parents can’t always see what their children are doing. We sometimes think we can pull one over on God too, but He is never distracted. In fact, He knew you were going to do it before you did!
Sneaky fingers
The next techinique, same granddaughter and similar in style, involves what I call sneaky fingers. Marilyn is not allowed to touch the keys on my computer. Of course she wants to do so– really bad. So her techinque is to stand and watch as if she has no interest in the keys. Soon a little hand slowly starts moving up toward the keys, slowly creeping upward with a final rush toward a key or two if she makes it close enough. This is a form of distraction and attempt to hide her intent as well.
Shhhhhhhhhhhhh!
The next technique I’ve seen in every child I’ve ever had in my care, but right now we’re discussing my two preschool grandchildren as my examples. My 4 yo grandson was just potty trained. Yes, it’s true. He did not want to do it, and he fought every attempt. His habit was to sneak off in a corner, an attempt to fly under the radar, and poop his pants. As soon as he finished, he’d go right back to playing until the stench told on him. Anytime kids are quiet . . . . Marilyn is really good at this. If she wants to do something, play with something, taste something, and has been told no, she will get very quiet, fall off the adult radar, and do whatever it was she wanted to do. This falls into the category of deciet and an attempt to hide the ‘sin’ as well.
Obedience with a but…
The final category involves obedience, but with a heart attitude. Outwardly, the obedience happens. Inwardly, not so much. Marilyn, when told no, stops what she’s doing and gets this hooded, gear-churning look on her face. She will stand there like that for a minute or more. She obeys, but Grandma knows she’s doing it out of duress and not because she wants to do it. This is the category many Christians fall into: I will obey you God, but in my heart, I’m really doing what I want. This is the most insidious of the categories as well, because the attitude of disobedience is still there.
Our determination to follow the rules, whether society’s, parents, or God’s, often begins and ends in the heart. We see a police car and obey the speed limit while in view. The minute we’re past, how many step on the gas and go right back to disobedience? Do we think it’s OK to do something if no one is looking? Do we step our toe over the line to see if we will get away with it?
Actions (or inactions) have consequences
Every thing we do or don’t do, every choice we make, every time we do something we know is not good for us or we’ve been told not to do, has a consquence. The consequences can be mild or major, they may happen now or later, but they will happen. Some of us decide experiencing the consquences is worth the momentary pleasures of the disobedience. Some of us obey — with a but. Some things have consequences for others. We think we’re not hurting anyone else by our choices, but that’s not true. Nothing we choose to do (or not do) happens in a vacuum. Your choices effect (and affect) others.
So, what’s the point? Ah, let’s go there. There is a reason parents give rules. There is a reason society gives rules. There is a reason God gives rules. Are they for our hurt? Absolutely not! {Disclaimer: I am aware some human beings may do things for our hurt – we’re talking about the rest of them.} Do children understand all the rules their parents give them? If only! We may not always understand why we need to do or not do something. Our obedience is not dependent on our understanding. A right heart obeys because it is the right thing to do. Understanding comes later.
Do you have a story about one of these techniques or others I have not included?
Have you ever used one of the above techniques or others to try to get your way?
Do you justify breaking rules or laws because you don’t agree with it or because it won’t hurt anyone?
What is your heart attitude? Are you chronically disobedient? Do you obey with a but…?
Feel free to add your stories, questions or comments to this post. You may be included in a future post 🙂
The following is for fun. Having the granddaughter here…..
Derek Mansker
Jan 14, 2012 @ 23:16:40
Well think about it like this: What does it mean to be free? We are not free in the sense we can do whatever we want. We are free to operate within a certain boundary- God’s. This is a great place to be, but there is that pesky me first attitude that gets in the way.
Yes, I have seen these in my kids and myself. One of my kids just likes the “I don’t want to” statement. That makes me wish he was a baby again. But, the lesson in right and wrong is daily.
Angela Young
Jan 15, 2012 @ 19:35:15
Thanks Derek, that’s very true and a very difficult concept to understand. I’m working on how to teach that other part of freedom to my kids. Yes, we all try to push the limits. Thanks for your comments:)
Red
Jan 15, 2012 @ 14:52:23
I often engage in civil disobedience because we have legislators who have no concept of the actual function of society outside their cloistered Senate walls. I am probably always guilty of obedient, but. While I can see the benefits in obedience, it is rarely for the sake of merely being obedient.
My children have come a long way toward being obedient, but, which is a victory in and of itself. Many times, as is the case with me, their questioning of “why” brings them to a place to understand the reasonableness of the rules. My rules are not truly many, but none of them are capricious, which makes it easier to garner obedience.
Red.
Angela Young
Jan 15, 2012 @ 19:38:23
I have to say that civil disobedience is not necessarily a bad thing. If something went against my beliefs, I might have to do so. That’s for another post, however. I like to believe most parents make reasonable rules, but I know many do not. The reasonableness of a rule isn’t dependent on understanding it, though. It’s a bit different with man’s laws than with parenting or God’s laws. Thanks for coming by 🙂
Red
Jan 16, 2012 @ 00:09:40
I see God’s laws and parenting in the same light. Take “Heavenly Father” into consideration. God’s law is not so different than the Momma Rules, hence the need for so few. Even if we do not understand at the first reading, not many “why”s get us to where we grasp the concept it is for our own good, like them or not. Free will dictates making an informed decision, even if the decision ultimately is to obey.
Man’s laws? Satan has a PO Box in Washington, DC. Many of them have no rhyme or reason, despite the majority vote it was a grand idea. (See repeal rate for a clue.)
Night, night!
Red.
Angela Young
Jan 16, 2012 @ 00:18:01
Ann Marie – great minds… See part II and III
elizabeth
Jan 15, 2012 @ 23:58:51
I love little kids. I love their brilliance. No one has to teach them how to be manipulative they just are. They can sus-out a situation faster that a brain surgeon and turn it to their advantage faster than an super-sonic jet. The fascinate me 🙂
And yes, I’m guilty of breaking many of the rules folks think God has set for me. Good thing He’s my Dad and loves me unconditionally 🙂 His love and discipline is never hurtful or mean. His lessons are taught with love and patience. I love that about Him.
Angela Young
Jan 16, 2012 @ 00:21:32
I love that about Him too, Elizabeth. You are right – kids are absolutely brilliant at guaging us adults and figuring out how to gain an advantage. My almost 2yo bats her eyes and say’s “pretty pretty” when she asks for candy. Who can resist? lol I learn so much about God and His parenting from watching them 🙂
nigelld
Jan 16, 2012 @ 06:49:18
There are many true words here that reflect in our house too. We have a 4 yo granddaughter and 1 yo grandson.
The one thing that really irritates is when they ask you and when they don’t get the answer they want they trot off to the other one hoping for a better response.
I’m also sorry I am that motorist as well, yet I could no more harm somebody deliberately than fly to the moon. My life is one big hypocrisy 😉
Nice article
Nigel
ansuyo
Jan 16, 2012 @ 12:05:34
Thank you Nigel 🙂 That’s one aspect I left out of this discussion – the playing one off the other. They are so good at sizing us up and seeking to get their way in whatever manner they can find. It’s cute in the younger children, but not so cute when adults still do it!
We are all hypocrits. Those who realize this have a heads-up, however, so that we can examine our hypocrisies and seek to change them. This aspect of the discussion is coming soon. Thanks for stopping by. Angie